First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. (FBPI) Stock Analysis

Why this analysis is different

• A 9-signal quantitative MoonshotScore built from filings, insider activity, and market data — computed from the numbers, not from opinion.
• An AI Council read across up to eight perspectives — value, macro, quantitative, and momentum lenses — that shows where they disagree instead of averaging the tension away.
• Figures come straight from FMP and Yahoo Finance filings data. The AI writes the narrative around the numbers — it never edits the numbers.

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. (FBPI) Financial Services Profile

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. functions as the bank holding company for First Federal Savings Bank, providing diverse banking products and services to individuals and businesses across Southwestern Indiana and Henderson, Kentucky. Established in 1904, the company focuses on community-based financial solutions, including various deposit accounts, mortgage, commercial, and consumer loans, alongside investment management and brokerage services.

What Is the Investment Thesis for FBPI?

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. presents a profile characterized by its long-standing regional banking presence and a focus on traditional community banking services. With a market capitalization of $25.9M, the company operates with a notable gross margin of 72.5% and a profit margin of 4.1%, indicating efficient management of its core banking operations. The company's low beta of 0.09 suggests minimal volatility relative to the broader market, potentially appealing to investors seeking stability. A dividend yield of 1.88% further highlights its commitment to shareholder returns. Key value drivers include its established customer base in Southwestern Indiana and Henderson, Kentucky, and its diversified loan portfolio spanning commercial, residential, and consumer segments. Ongoing catalysts could include sustained regional economic growth, which would drive demand for both deposits and loans, and continued prudent management of its investment securities portfolio. Investors may want to evaluate the company's regional concentration and the inherent risks associated with the banking sector, such as interest rate fluctuations and credit risk, particularly given its OTC market listing.

Based on FMP financials and quantitative analysis

FBPI Key Highlights

A market capitalization of $25.9M reflects First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc.'s position as a smaller, regionally focused financial institution.

• The company maintains a gross margin of 72.5%, indicating strong operational efficiency in its core banking services.
• First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. reported a profit margin of 4.1%, demonstrating its ability to generate net income from its revenue.
• With a beta of 0.09, the stock exhibits very low volatility, suggesting it is less sensitive to broader market movements compared to many other equities.
• Shareholders benefit from a dividend yield of 1.88%, indicating a consistent return on investment for equity holders.

Who Are FBPI's Competitors?

FBPI is benchmarked below against 8 industry peers on price, market cap, and our AI MoonshotScore.

AI Score by Stock Expert AI · Price data: FMP / Yahoo Finance

What Are FBPI's Key Strengths?

Long operating history since 1904, fostering strong community trust and brand recognition.

• Diversified loan portfolio across commercial, residential, and consumer segments.
• Established physical presence with 9 full-service offices in Southwestern Indiana and a Kentucky loan office.
• Strong gross margin of 72.5% indicating efficient core operations.

What Are FBPI's Weaknesses?

Small market capitalization of $25.9M, potentially limiting access to capital markets.

• Regional concentration exposes the company to localized economic downturns.
• Reliance on traditional banking models may present challenges in adapting to rapid fintech innovation.
• Trades on the OTC market, which can imply lower liquidity and less stringent reporting requirements.

What Could Drive FBPI Stock Higher?

FBPI catalyst: **Regional Economic Growth:** Sustained economic expansion in Southwestern Indiana and Henderson, Kentucky, could drive increased demand for commercial and residential loans, boosting the bank's net interest income.

• **Prudent Loan Portfolio Management:** Continued effective management of its diverse loan portfolio, minimizing non-performing assets, will support consistent profitability and asset quality.
• **Digital Service Enhancements:** Successful implementation and adoption of new digital banking features or mobile capabilities could attract new customers and improve operational efficiency, expanding the bank's reach.
• **Stable Interest Rate Environment:** A stable or moderately increasing interest rate environment could improve net interest margins, enhancing the bank's core profitability from lending activities.

What Are the Key Risks for FBPI?

Financial-distress signal — its Altman Z-Score of 0.09 sits in the distress zone (elevated bankruptcy risk).

• **Interest Rate Fluctuations:** Significant changes in interest rates could negatively impact the bank's net interest margin, affecting profitability from its loan and deposit products.
• **Credit Risk Exposure:** As a lender, First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. is continuously exposed to the risk of loan defaults, particularly in its commercial and residential mortgage portfolios, which could lead to increased loan loss provisions.
• **Regional Economic Downturn:** A severe economic contraction in Southwestern Indiana or Henderson, Kentucky, could reduce loan demand, increase unemployment, and lead to higher loan delinquencies.
• **Regulatory Compliance Burden:** The banking industry is heavily regulated, and ongoing changes in compliance requirements could increase operational costs and complexity for the company.
• **Competition from Fintech and Larger Banks:** Increased competition from digital-first fintech companies and larger, more technologically advanced regional or national banks could erode market share and pricing power.

What Are the Growth Opportunities for FBPI?

• **Digital Banking Enhancement and Expansion:** Investing in advanced digital banking platforms, including mobile applications, online account opening, and enhanced cybersecurity features, presents a significant growth avenue. This strategy can attract younger demographics and improve operational efficiency, expanding the bank's reach beyond its physical branch network. The market for digital financial services continues to grow, driven by consumer preference for convenience, with projections indicating substantial increases in mobile banking adoption rates over the next five years. By offering a seamless digital experience, First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. can enhance customer retention and acquire new clients who prioritize digital accessibility.
• **Targeted Geographic Expansion in Adjacent Markets:** While currently serving Southwestern Indiana and Henderson, Kentucky, there are opportunities to strategically expand into adjacent underserved or growing communities within these states. This could involve opening additional loan production offices or smaller, digitally-focused branch formats rather than full-service branches, minimizing capital expenditure. Identifying specific sub-markets with strong economic indicators and limited competitive saturation could allow First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. to capture new deposit and lending market share. This expansion could be executed over a 3-5 year timeline, carefully assessing each new location's potential.
• **Niche Lending Product Development:** Developing and marketing specialized loan products tailored to specific local industries or demographic needs can create new revenue streams. For instance, given its regional focus, the bank could explore agricultural lending, specialized small business administration (SBA) loans for local entrepreneurs, or specific real estate development financing that aligns with regional growth patterns. These niche products often command higher margins and foster stronger, more specialized client relationships. The timeline for developing and rolling out such products could range from 12 to 24 months, following thorough market research and risk assessment.
• **Expansion of Wealth Management and Advisory Services:** Building out a more robust suite of wealth management, financial planning, and investment advisory services can deepen customer relationships and generate non-interest income. As customers accumulate wealth, they often seek comprehensive financial guidance beyond traditional banking products. By offering these services, First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. can capture a larger share of its customers' financial portfolios and attract new high-net-worth clients. This expansion could be a multi-year initiative, requiring investment in skilled personnel and technology, but offers significant long-term revenue potential.
• **Strategic Mergers and Acquisitions with Smaller Community Banks:** The regional banking sector often sees consolidation. First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. could pursue strategic acquisitions of smaller, complementary community banks within its operating region. Such acquisitions could immediately expand its branch network, customer base, and asset size, leading to economies of scale and increased market share. This approach could also provide access to new talent and technologies. The timeline for such opportunities is opportunistic, depending on market conditions and the availability of suitable targets, but could offer substantial growth within a 2-4 year horizon if a suitable partner is identified and integrated effectively.

What Are FBPI's Competitive Advantages?

• **Established Local Presence:** Over a century of operation since 1904 has built deep roots and trust within the Southwestern Indiana community.
• **Customer Relationships:** Long-standing relationships with local businesses and individuals create a loyal customer base, fostering repeat business and referrals.
• **Regional Market Knowledge:** In-depth understanding of local economic conditions, real estate markets, and business needs allows for tailored product offerings and risk assessment.
• **Diversified Loan Portfolio:** A mix of commercial, residential, and consumer loans helps mitigate risk and provides multiple revenue streams within its regional focus.

What Does FBPI Do?

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc., established in 1904 and headquartered in Evansville, Indiana, serves as the bank holding company for First Federal Savings Bank. This long-standing financial institution has evolved over more than a century to provide a comprehensive array of banking products and services tailored to both individual and business customers within its regional footprint. The company's core operations revolve around traditional banking activities, including accepting various types of deposits such as checking, savings, money market, and certificates of deposit, which form the essential funding base for its lending activities. On the lending side, First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. offers a diverse portfolio of loan products. These include commercial one-to-four family mortgage loans, commercial and multi-family mortgage loans, secured and unsecured commercial business loans, residential one-to-four family mortgage loans, residential second mortgage loans, and various consumer loans. Additionally, the company provides home equity lines of credit, offering flexible financing options to its clientele. Beyond core deposit and lending services, First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. is actively involved in the management of investment securities portfolios, contributing to its overall financial stability and revenue streams. Complementary services further enhance its customer offerings, encompassing safe deposit box services, check cashing and cashier's check services, wire transfers, and brokerage services, providing a holistic financial experience. The company maintains a physical presence with 9 full-service offices strategically located across Southwestern Indiana, ensuring accessibility and personalized service for its local communities. Furthermore, it operates 1 loan production office in Henderson, Kentucky, extending its reach and lending capabilities into a neighboring market. This community-focused, diversified service model underpins First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc.'s market position within the regional banking sector.

What Products and Services Does FBPI Offer?

• Operates as a bank holding company for First Federal Savings Bank.
• Accepts various types of deposits, including checking, savings, money market, and certificates of deposit.
• Offers commercial loans, such as one-to-four family mortgage, multi-family mortgage, and secured/unsecured business loans.
• Provides residential loans, including one-to-four family mortgage and second mortgage loans.
• Extends consumer loans and home equity lines of credit to individuals.
• Manages investment securities portfolios to generate income and maintain liquidity.
• Offers supplementary services like safe deposit boxes, check cashing, wire transfers, and brokerage services.
• Operates 9 full-service banking offices in Southwestern Indiana and 1 loan production office in Henderson, Kentucky.

How Does FBPI Make Money?

• Generates interest income primarily from its diverse loan portfolio (commercial, residential, consumer) and investment securities.
• Earns non-interest income through service charges on deposit accounts, fees from brokerage services, wire transfers, and other banking services.
• Manages a deposit base from individuals and businesses to fund lending activities, paying interest on these deposits.
• Operates with a community banking model, focusing on local relationships and personalized service within its specific geographic markets.

What Industry Does FBPI Operate In?

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. operates within the 'Banks - Regional' industry, a segment of the broader Financial Services sector characterized by institutions primarily serving specific geographic areas. This industry is often influenced by local economic conditions, population growth, and regional business activity. Regional banks like First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. typically compete on factors such as customer service, local market knowledge, and community engagement, differentiating themselves from larger national banks. Current market trends include an increasing demand for digital banking solutions, evolving regulatory landscapes, and competitive pressures on interest rate margins. First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc., with its 9 full-service offices in Southwestern Indiana and a loan production office in Henderson, Kentucky, is positioned as a community-centric provider, leveraging its long history since 1904 to maintain established customer relationships and local market expertise.

Who Are FBPI's Key Customers?

• Individual consumers seeking deposit accounts, residential mortgages, consumer loans, and personal banking services.
• Small to medium-sized businesses requiring commercial loans, business banking accounts, and treasury management services.
• Real estate developers and investors seeking commercial and multi-family mortgage financing.
• Local community members utilizing supplementary services like safe deposit boxes and wire transfers.

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. (FBPI) Valuation Context

Valued at $25.9M, FBPI is classified as a micro-cap stock. Relative to its peer group, FBPI's quantitative score of 49/100 is below the peer average of 92/100.

FBPI Revenue & Earnings Trend

In Q1 2026, FBPI generated $8.2M in top-line revenue, marking a sequential decrease of 8.3%. The company recorded net income of $261K, with diluted EPS of $0.15. Quarter-over-quarter revenue has been mixed, typical for a micro-cap company operating in Financial Services. Across the four most recent quarters, FBPI averaged $0.23 in diluted EPS.

Company Profile

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. operates in the Banks - Regional industry within the Financial Services sector. It is headquartered in Evansville, US. The company is led by CEO Michael H. Head. FBPI has traded publicly since 2008.

Return on equity for First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. stands at 4.8%, a gauge of how efficiently it converts shareholder capital into profit. Return on assets is 0.3%, showing how much profit it generates from its asset base. FBPI trades at a trailing price-to-earnings ratio of 15.68, below the Financial Services sector average of ~18x. Its free cash flow yield is 0.0%, a gauge of the cash the business throws off relative to its market value. A current ratio of 0.00 means current liabilities exceed short-term assets, a liquidity point worth watching. Its earnings yield is 6.4%, the inverse of the P/E and a quick read on earnings relative to price.

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc.'s Piotroski F-Score is 4/9, a 9-point checklist of profitability, leverage and efficiency — a middling fundamental profile. Its Altman Z-Score of 0.09 places it in the distress zone, a signal of elevated financial risk.

FBPI Financials

FBPI Latest News

No recent news available for FBPI.

FBPI Analyst Consensus

FBPI MoonshotScore

First Bancorp of Indiana, Inc. Financial Services Stock: Key Questions Answered

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always do your own research and consult a financial advisor.

Official Resources