Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGIP) Stock Price & Analysis
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGIP) — MoonshotScore 77/100 (Strong band), calculated Nov 18, 2026. Price $14.82 (+1.44%), as of the Nov 19, 2026 trading session; market cap $5.80B. Expected results Feb 4, 2027.
Educational signal · not a buy or sell recommendation · How to read this
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. · SIGIP · Financial Services · Insurance - Property & Casualty
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered): Selective Insurance underwrites property and casualty insurance through distinct business divisions: standard commercial lines, standard personal lines, excess and surplus lines, and an investment portfolio. Selective operates as a publicly traded underwriter whose profit depends on underwriting discipline and investment returns combined. Success hinges on maintaining underwriting margins while using a large investment portfolio to offset underwriting losses in volatile market cycles.
Price as of Nov 19, 2026
Key Statistics
MoonshotScore v2 · Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP)
StrongWhy this rating? Method, drivers & history
Bands for the MoonshotScore: Exceptional 80-100 · Strong 65-79 · Fair 45-64 · Weak below 45.
- Business Quality — Is this a genuinely good business?
- Financial Safety — Could this blow up on me?
- Valuation — Am I paying a fair price?
- Growth Durability — Is the growth real and likely to last?
- Momentum — Is the market already moving on this?
High quality and durable growth, at a dirt-cheap price, though the balance sheet is only decent, and the price trend has turned against it. Business Quality: Elite; Financial Safety: Sound; Valuation: Cheap; Growth Durability: Compounding; Momentum: Slipping.
- quarterly revenue $1.33B (Q3 FY2026, quarter ended Sep 30, 2026)
- EPS beat 3 of the last 8 reports
- Altman Z 1.90 · Piotroski F 6
Holding back: weak price trend
Helping: business quality, an attractive price, durable growth
What has the MoonshotScore done over time?
| Recorded | Score | Band |
|---|---|---|
| 90 | Exceptional | |
| 88 | Exceptional | |
| 91 | Exceptional | |
| 91 | Exceptional | |
| 77 | Strong | |
| 77 | Strong |
Daily score refresh is delayed. This is the last recorded calculation.
Calculation uses the most recent completed US trading session. Live price changes do not update the score immediately.
Computed · How the MoonshotScore is computed →
Price & valuation
| Measure | Value | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Latest provided price | $14.82 | |
| Change on the day | +1.44% | |
| 52-week range | $14.49–$17.49 | |
| Market capitalisation | $5.80B | |
| Price / earnings (trailing) | 12.30 | |
| Shares traded on the day | 22.3K | |
| Beta (volatility vs the S&P 500) | 0.21 |
Price & events
Triangles mark reported quarters on the line: pointing up is above the recorded estimate, down is below, a diamond means no estimate on file. Numbers key to the dated list. Point at or tab to any week for its close.
Events behind the price
- · Earnings results · above the recorded estimate
- · Earnings results · below the recorded estimate
- · Earnings results · above the recorded estimate
- · Earnings results · above the recorded estimate
Results dates follow the earnings feed; call dates follow the transcript provider. Nearby dates do not establish that an event caused a price move.
Upcoming events
How to read these dates
Estimated dates can change.
Other perspectives
Council score for Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP): perspectives
Council is a separate blend of available disciplines; MoonshotScore above remains the five-pillar research rating.
5-Factor Breakdown
Legends Council
6 lenses, 0 current
AI simulations built from the named investors' published principles. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, or the opinion of these individuals. How these lenses are built
Read on: Sep 8, 2026 · older than the 27 hours refresh window; not a current reading
Munger's Mindset
Balance Sheet & Valuation · historical
Read on: May 1, 2026 · older than the 27 hours refresh window; not a current reading
How to read these bars and different assessments
Council is a separate blend of available disciplines; MoonshotScore above remains the five-pillar research rating.
Bars show each model's ordered assessment on its own scale, not a probability or a comparable investment return. The adjacent words give the assessment; more filled segments indicate a stronger model reading.
On May 1, 2026, the Munger lens read the price at that time as undervalued against its own estimate of value.
Readings on this page are from Nov 20, 2026, except a card that shows its own read date.
What is Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP), and what does it report?
Short answer · as of
Selective is a casualty insurer, not a life or health company. Revenue consists of net premiums earned plus investment income.
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered).
The company's reported earnings reflect underwriting gains or losses, plus realized and unrealized gains on its substantial securities holdings. Premium growth comes from rate increases and customer retention in existing markets, plus selective expansion into excess and surplus lines—riskier business that commands higher premiums and higher loss volatility.
What do the latest results show for Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP)?
Short answer · as of
The most recent reported quarter, Q3 FY2026, carried revenue of $1.33B.
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered).
Latest quarters show underwriting profit margins improving, with operating margins in the double digits and net margins strong. Premium revenue grew modestly while expense control tightened. The company's investment portfolio appreciated, contributing meaningfully to net income. Management's tone suggests confidence in renewal rate environment, indicating that customers accept price increases rather than shopping for competitors. Watch next quarter to confirm whether underwriting discipline persists or gives way to competitive pressure.
Where is operating spending going?
Revenue alongside research and development, selling, general and administrative expenses, and the FMP standardized operating result.
| Period end | Revenue | R&D | SG&A | FMP standardized operating result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2026 | Not available | Not available | Not available | Not available |
| Jun 30, 2026 | Not available | Not available | Not available | Not available |
| Mar 31, 2026 | Not available | Not available | Not available | Not available |
| Dec 31, 2025 | Not available | Not available | Not available | Not available |
How to read these figures
Amounts are in US dollars. The operating result is Financial Modeling Prep’s standardized figure, so it can differ from the operating line in the company’s filing. It is not net income or cash flow.
Did results meet expectations?
Reported earnings and revenue alongside the estimates recorded by the provider.
- Latest report · revenue
- $1.12B Oct 22, 2026
- Latest report · revenue estimate
- $1.17B Oct 22, 2026
- Latest report · revenue vs estimate
- Below estimate Oct 22, 2026
- Latest report · EPS vs estimate
- Above estimate Oct 22, 2026
| Report date | Revenue · reported | Revenue · estimate | EPS · reported | EPS · estimate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 22, 2026 | $1.12B | $1.17B | $2.3700 | $1.9100 |
| Jul 23, 2026 | $1.22B | $1.30B | $1.9500 | $1.6600 |
| Apr 22, 2026 | $1.23B | $1.29B | $1.6900 | $1.8000 |
| Jan 29, 2026 | $1.13B | $1.14B | $2.5700 | $2.0200 |
How to read these figures
Dates are when results were reported, not quarter ends. Amounts are in US dollars; EPS is per share. The source does not say whether EPS is basic, diluted or adjusted, so it can differ from the EPS in the income statement.
Quarterly income statement — 4 quarters
| Period | Revenue | Net income | EPS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 FY2026 | $1.33B | $129M | $2.11 (diluted) |
| Q2 FY2026 | $1.39B | $129M | $2.11 (diluted) |
| Q1 FY2026 | $1.35B | $98M | $1.58 (diluted) |
| Q4 FY2025 | $1.36B | $155M | $2.52 (diluted) |
What are the financial strengths and risks for Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP)?
Short answer · as of
Cash and short-term investments were $0.00 at the Sep 30, 2026 balance-sheet date. This figure does not establish a cash runway.
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered).
Selective holds a large investment portfolio—long-term investments dwarf cash reserves. The company carries moderate leverage relative to equity, and investment income covers a meaningful portion of operating expenses. A sharp decline in bond valuations or equity markets would erode surplus and reduce the buffer against underwriting losses. Conversely, in years when underwriting is weak, investment gains can rescue net income and dividend capacity.
What should you watch next at Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP)?
Short answer · as of
The next earnings report is expected on Feb 4, 2027.
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered).
Monitor underwriting ratios each quarter—loss ratios trending up would signal tougher claims experience or inadequate pricing. Track premium growth rates to see whether the company is gaining or losing market share. Observe dividend sustainability; if underwriting deteriorates, dividend cuts often follow within quarters. Finally, watch interest rate expectations; falling rates hurt reinvestment yields and can force the company into lower-quality credits to maintain income.
What the records here don't tell us
- No forward revenue or earnings estimate is on file.
Checked against the records this page reads, on the dates shown above.
How does Selective Insurance Group compare with its peers?
Short answer
Selective Insurance Group's score ranks 11th of 13 in the bounded comparison shown, against 12 same-model peers. These are company scores, not expected investment returns. The set lists named competitors first, then companies in the same data-provider industry classification closest in market value; that classification is the provider's, not our judgment of business similarity.
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered).
Selective differs from larger national carriers by concentrating in middle-market commercial and personal lines where underwriting discipline can offer a competitive edge over mass-market competitors. The company is smaller than industry giants like State Farm or GEICO, which limits geographic scale but enables nimble underwriting decisions. A regional bias toward the Northeast gives Selective expertise in snow-and-weather-related claims, a specialized knowledge asset that larger carriers may not privilege. The trade-off is concentration risk in a high-cost geography.
| Company | Price | Market value | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| $26.85 Nov 19, 2026 | $3.15B | 100 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $190.82 Nov 18, 2026 | $2.37B | 99 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $71.35 Nov 18, 2026 | $6.55B | 98 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $244.84 Nov 18, 2026 | $8.42B | 97 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $398.47 Nov 18, 2026 | $8.97B | 94 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $156.87 Nov 19, 2026 | $13.0B | 94 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $157.44 Nov 18, 2026 | $4.14B | 91 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $2220.81 Nov 18, 2026 | $5.30B | 88 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $63.53 Nov 18, 2026 | $2.82B | 86 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $82.59 Nov 19, 2026 | $4.74B | 79 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| Selective Insurance Group (SIGIP) — this page | $14.82 | $5.80B | 77 |
| $47.72 Nov 19, 2026 | $12.9B | 63 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 | |
| $16.22 Nov 18, 2026 | $5.57B | 56 5-pillar Nov 18, 2026 |
Only 5-pillar scores are ranked together. Other models are not directly comparable. Price and score dates are shown separately; market-value dates are unavailable.
The records behind this page
Insider activity
Form 4 records via FMP · Of the newest 60 records, those within the last 180 days, newest dated Nov 9, 2026
- Transactions
- 5
- Identified insiders
- 3
- Purchases
- 0
- Sales
- 2
- Other transactions
- 3
Purchases and sales use the reported transaction category. Other transactions include awards, exercises, gifts, withholding and unclassified activity; an acquisition or disposition alone is not a purchase or sale. These records do not establish intent.
Who holds the shares?
Institutional ownership reported through 13F filings.
Tracked investors
Which of the 16 named investors we follow held SIGIP in their latest 13F filing, and what they did against the filing before it.
None of the 16 tracked investors reported SIGIP in their latest 13F filing.
How to read these figures
These filings arrive after the quarter ends. Names appear as the provider lists them, not as a verified ranking, and without filing dates. Related managers can appear separately, so their shares are not added together. Tracked investors: each fund's own latest 13F, so funds that have not filed the newest quarter yet show their previous one; weight is the share of the fund's reported 13F value.
Common Questions About SIGIP (Financial Services)
Research dated 2026-09-13 (results through Q2 FY2026; Q3 FY2026 not covered); the full attribution is under Sources. The last question is answered from this page's own dated data, not from the research.
How does Selective make money?
The company collects premiums, pays claims and operating expenses, and deploys a large investment portfolio. Underwriting profit comes from charging premiums that exceed the present value of expected claims plus expenses. Investment income provides a second earnings source, often enough to carry years when underwriting is weak.
What risks push underwriting losses?
Weather catastrophes, medical-inflation outpacing rate increases, or errors in reserving for known claims. The company's concentration in the Northeast exposes it to winter storms and nor'easters. A prolonged labor shortage pushing auto-repair costs higher could force reserve takedowns.
Is the dividend safe?
The company has paid and grown dividends consistently through underwriting cycles. Dividend yield sits near historical levels, suggesting management believes current underwriting and investment returns can sustain the payout. A sustained decline in interest rates or a major catastrophe year could pressure the dividend.
How does Selective compete with national carriers?
Selective competes through underwriting expertise in middle-market commercial lines and selective personal lines. The company claims advantage in pricing accuracy and claims handling speed compared to larger, less agile competitors. The trade-off is lower brand awareness and lower premium volume per agent, which requires higher operating margins to survive.
What is the SIGIP stock price today?
The last price recorded for Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGIP), with its trading session and source, is listed under Price & valuation on this page. It is a provider snapshot, not a live exchange feed, so check a brokerage quote before you trade.
Research written by Claude (claude-haiku-4-5) on 2026-09-13. AI-authored analysis; source dates are listed under Sources. Editorial oversight is systemic, not page-by-page. Editorially accountable: Sedat ANAK, Founder and Editor-in-Chief.
Sources: the source register lists the 40 figures on this page — 35 from Financial Modeling Prep (FMP), 2 with no recorded source, 2 computed by us, formula shown in the register and 1 from Stock Expert AI's own score and rank. Its rows (value as shown, as-of date, tier and source link) are in the Markdown version of this page.
Publication details and research sources
- Published
- Research standards
- Methodology · Editorial policy · Corrections
- Report a number
- sedat@stockexpertai.com